△ MENU/TOP △

Holtz Communications + Technology

Shel Holtz
Communicating at the Intersection of Business and Technology
SearchClose Icon

What we have here…

Imagine sending out a press kit containing nothing but blank pages because the photocopier stopped working after the first three or four copies. Or distributing a VNR that contains 10 minutes of baseball because somebody taped over the original video. No doubt there have been glitches in PR tactics, but most practitioners work hard to make sure the material they’re sending out to target audiences meets professional standards.

Evidently, you can’t say the same thing about online campaigns. Seventy-five percent of online campaigns suffer from website failures, and in 14% of the cases, the failures are so bad they keep the campaign from meeting its objectives.

That’s the result of a study titled Internet Campaign Effectiveness Study, released by SciViscum, a web testing agency. The key problem is that the campaigns are being implemented by people with a limited knowledge of the technology they’re using. Some 66% of marketing professionals didn’t even know their sites’ capacities for user transactions. Another problem: an ongoing “communication chasm” between the marketers and the IT staff. Twenty-five percent of companies with marketing campaigns underwent server overloads and crashes directly resulting from the failure of the two departments to communicate with one another. Amazingly, 26% of marketing departments don’t even inform IT that a new campaign is coming and 52% rarely or never work with IT before a new online campaign starts.

Imagine failing to notify your printer that a new publication is on its way. The IT department is, for all practical purposes, the printer of the digital age. The only time it makes sense to circumvent IT is when you’re employing outside expertise to develop a campaign that does not use company resources—but even then, your contract with outside consultants simply shifts the IT role from internal to external experts.

I had thought the IT/communications rift was over, a remnant of the struggle for control of the web that erupted in the mid-1990s. If the SciViscum report is accurate (and I have no reason to doubt its validity), the battle continues—at the expense of effectiveness and even reputation.

As a communicator, how do you work with your IT staff?

08/08/05 | 1 Comment | What we have here…

Comments
  • 1.One role I have served for years with my clients is the un-official liaison between PR/Marketing and IT. Some of the problems stem from the fact that communicators often think in broad terms, i.e. how, when, why, who...etc while IT is sometimes binary, Yes/No.

    Here is a common scenario:

    Marketing (asking IT): We'd like to create a better solution for the distribution of our internal communications, we want to modify the following intranet pages to ....

    IT: No, we run a Domino based system and ......

    Then I come in. It's sad but I often construct a series of basic Yes/No questions to lead the IT folks in the direction we want. Something like this...

    Me: Domino uses a basic include system to generate pages correct?

    IT: Yes

    Me: I know the files are not a typical HTML page and are not named as such, but it does use HTML correct?

    IT: Yes

    Me: You have the ability to control which header and footer includes are used at the page level correct?

    IT: Yes

    Me: If we provided you all the HTML for the new includes then all you would have to do is cut-paste in the new code, correct?

    IT: Yes

    This is the interesting part, you see the light go on and it's either one of two things.

    1. They've worked through the steps and realized it's actually an easy fix and are happy to do the work, and will sometimes take some initiative themselves.

    2. They're pissed because you out-smarted them and now realize they have to do the work.

    Josh Hallett | August 2005 | Celebration, FL

Comment Form

« Back