△ MENU/TOP △

Holtz Communications + Technology

Shel Holtz
Communicating at the Intersection of Business and Technology
SearchClose Icon

If you can’t say anything nice…

My mother taught me that if I can’t say anything nice about somebody, don’t say anything. So when Steve Rubel endorsed John Kerry for president on Micropersuasion, I just kept my blog shut. Frank Barnako’s mom may have missed that lesson, though, because today the CBS Marketwatch managing editor did say something: “Seve Rubel endorsed a presidential candidate yesterday. His blog usually concentrates on public relations. The idea of a blogger making an endorsement, as if he carried any weight, was presumptuous. Now venture capitalist Fred Wilson has followed the leader.  Visit the site.

Barnako went first, so now I don’t feel like I have to keep quiet any more. I have a pretty strong position myself on the election, but my blog is about communications and, usually, the impact of technology on the business. Having written some books that sold pretty well on the topic, I get asked about the Net, the Web and intranets a lot. I’m considered an authority. That doesn’t mean anybody gives a damn if I’m a Bushie or a Kerryite, and what I think sure as hell isn’t going to influence anybody’s vote. I doubt Steve’s “endorsement” will cause anyone to say, “Damn! I was going to vote for Bush, but Steve Rubel’s endorsing Kerry, so…I was wrong! Thank God Steve set me straight! If it weren’t for Steve, my misguided vote might have spelled catastrophe for the nation and the world!”

I thought Steve’s blog was about PR. Now I’m not sure what it’s about, other than being about one entry too long.

12/22/04 | 9 Comments | If you can’t say anything nice…

Comments
  • 1.Shel, thank you for your thoughtful feedback. My blog is and will always be about PR. My "endorsement" was more a call to the Kerry campaign to treat catalogue their blog endorsements like media - just as DNC opened the gates to blogges. It was really aboutu PR and I was very clear I was not trying to sway opinions (as if I could).

    Steve Rubel | October 2004 | New York

  • 2.Rubel for President!

    Robb Hecht | October 2004 | New York

  • 3.Oh yeah and now you see I can't really spell either. Great. My credibility is now zero!

    Steve Rubel | October 2004 | New York

  • 4.I meant: Rubel for Prezident! :-)

    Robb Hecht | October 2004 | New York

  • 5.Nothing personal, Steve -- I just couldn't leave Barnako's comments untouched!

    Shel Holtz | October 2004 | Concord, CA

  • 6.Isn't it funny how this post gets responses and my substantive posts get zero. I wonder what that says about blogs!

    Shel Holtz | October 2004 | Concord, CA

  • 7.None taken.

    Steve Rubel | October 2004 | New York

  • 8.Poynter picked up the Rubel piece as well in E-Media Tidbits.

    I commented on Rubel's blog about my thoughts on political endorsements and PR blogs.

    And, all Jewish mothers say that, but then they are such yentas!!

    Jeremy | October 2004 | AZ

  • 9.

    But how to do it? Shel, Steve and their correspondents argue about this. Here’s one answer: To be influential, blogs, like brands or political campaigns, must never waver. They must be focused and on-message, every time. Rubel cannot long meander off…

Comment Form

« Back