△ MENU/TOP △

Holtz Communications + Technology

Shel Holtz
Communicating at the Intersection of Business and Technology
SearchClose Icon

Memo to PRWeek: Streaming videos are not podcasts

I was intrigued by the PRWeek headline: “Free podcasts become driving force in BMW branding push.” The “free” bit wasn’t the hook; after all, only a handful of the 70,000 or so podcasts available require a fee, and BMW isn’t going to attract the same fervent desire for its podcasts as Ricky Gervais. No, it was the fact that BMW had turned to podcasts to aid its branding that made me curious. I was also impressed with the approach. The alleged podcasts were videos shot at the exclusive Technology, Entertainment, Design (TED) conference.

So I cruised on over to the site referenced in the write-up and found…wait for it…streaming videos. Nowhere on the site could the word “podcast” be found. Good thing, too, since a subscription feed is what separates a podcast from other online multimedia. Even if you dismiss the RSS requirement, you would still think a podcast could be played on, well, you know, a video iPod. (That’s even part of the Oxford English Dictionary’s definition of a podcast.) But these videos can’t be downloaded. They just play as streams in pop-up windows on the web page. They are decidedly not podcasts.

Which is not an issue from BMW’s perspective, since the automaker never claimed they were. (Interestingly, you can both subscribe and download from the TED site.) And I applaud BMW for linking their stylish cars to the premier design conference, not to mention getting videos out of what has historically been a very closed meeting. I even like the headline on the page, a send-up of the Las Vegas tourism campaign: “What happens at TED stays at TED. Until now.”

It appears PRWeek just chose to call these streaming videos “podcasts.” Surely the editors know the difference, since PRWeek has a few podcasts of its own, complete with subscription feeds. So what on earth prompted them to mislabel BMW’s videos?

Befuddling.

Technorati Tags: ,

Comments
  • 1.When you're right, you're right.

    As you point out, TED does make the podcasts available on its Web site. BMW only provides streaming video. Our mistake. I've amended the story online to reflect this.

    Thanks for pointing it out.

    Keith | July 2006

  • 2.Shel, my guess is that either:
    1. They are trying to cash in on the podcast cachet or
    2. It's an honest mistake

    Every few weeks I get a call from someone who needs help with a "podcast," except it ain't really a podcast. It's usually downloadable audio they desire. Sigh. We have a lot of work ahead of us, eh?

    donna papacosta | July 2006 | Toronto

  • 3.Donna, I'm sure it was an honest mistake, and my intent isn't to cast snark at PRWeek. But podcasting is confusing enough to a lot of people -- including many of those in the PR industry -- without the industry's publication of record adding to the confusion. So thanks and credit to Keith and PRWeek for seeing the problem and making the adjustment!

    Shel Holtz | July 2006 | Concord, CA

Comment Form

« Back