△ MENU/TOP △

Holtz Communications + Technology

Shel Holtz
Communicating at the Intersection of Business and Technology
SearchClose Icon

PR practitioners as journalists

Public relations practitioners increasingly are using the Internet as a channel to get information into the hands of its audiences. This process bypasses traditional media. That’s great because we don’t have to worry about how traditional news media will filter our messages. It’s also troublesome because we can no longer rely on traditional news media to screen our content for accuracy.

According to Richard Edelman, president and CEO of Edelman Public Relations Worldwide, this means the PR profession needs to start behaving more like journalists. In an interview in Canada’s Globe and Mail, Edelman said, “If we’re just putting stuff up [on the Internet] and people are reading it and accepting it as truth, then we should have a journalist-level quality as our objective instead of a promoter objective.”

My degree is in journalism and I was a newspaper reporter in the mid-1970’s for a brief time before moving into corporate communications. Despite two years in the newspaper game compared to nearly 30 in corporate communications, the notions of accuracy and fact-checking have always been an inherent part of my approach to my work. I have to wonder, though, about the agencies reaping massive billable hours from government agencies to produce VNRs and getting small TV news outlets to air them as unattributed news reports. How quickly will these agencies embrace the ideal that their first responsibility is to the truth?

Edelman has the right idea. Theonly question is how to spread the religion through the profession.

03/22/05 | 5 Comments | PR practitioners as journalists

Comments
  • 1.The PR profession will get religion the same way accounting did, when they are hauled up before congress and grilled for their role in the misappropriation of taxpayer money.

    It's not just the local TV stations who are to blame, it seems the networks took money from the federal government to distribute the Potemkin reports, so I suspect we will see network management hauled up before Congress as well.

    http://technoflak.blogspot.com/2005/03/crony-journalism-goes-nationwide.html

    It will end as all these scandals do, in a great review of the email records and a huge boost to the records management/document management industry.

    Alice Marshall | March 2005

  • 2.Aha. As a journalist, do I see salvation? Throw out all the PR operatives and replace them with the journalists they're trying to side-step.

    David Tebbutt | March 2005 | London, England

  • 3.All the PR operatives, David? You've never worked with a practitioner who was genuinely helpful and collaborated with you in your process of producing news? Not once? And are all journalists equipped to advocate on behalf of the organizations they would represent if they stepped into such a role?

    Shel Holtz | March 2005 | Concord, CA

  • 4.Hey - that was meant to be light-hearted. I think most journalists would run a mile from such a job. (I suppose you'll give me a hard time for this remark too.)

    David Tebbutt | March 2005 | London, England

  • 5.Sorry, David...I missed the light-heartedness. Cultural differences, I suppose! And no, I won't give you a hard time. In fact, I'm grateful for your comments.

    Shel Holtz | March 2005 | Concord, CA

Comment Form

« Back